Digital resources in the Social Sciences and Humanities OpenEdition Our platforms OpenEdition Books OpenEdition Journals Hypotheses Calenda Libraries OpenEdition Freemium Follow us

Workshop Report: Protest Event Analysis in the Covid-19 Pandemic: Methodological challenges and new ideas

Workshop Report: Protest Event Analysis in the Covid-19 Pandemic: Methodological challenges and new ideas

Author: Elisabeth Oertel 

On 10 October 2022, international researchers met for the second time to discuss research results and new approaches in Protest Event Analysis (PEA) and to present them to an audience. The workshop “Protest Event Analysis in the Covid-19 Pandemic: Methodological Challenges and New Ideas” was hosted by the Institute of Philosophy and Sociology of the Polish Academy of Sciences (IFiS PAN) together with HAIT. It is the result of their cooperation with the Institute for Protest and Social Movement Studies (ipb), funded by the German-Polish Science Foundation (DPWS).

As part of an international cooperation initiative with IFiS PAN and ipb, on 1 November 2021, researchers at HAIT began working on a DPWS-funded project which aimed to analyse and compare protests against Covid-19 measures (“anti-corona protests”) in Poland with those in Germany, specifically in Saxony and Baden-Württemberg. In addition to investigating protest events themselves, the project also advances Protest Event Analysis in a cross-border context methodologically, identifies new data sources, and further strengthens networks between the Polish and German scientific landscapes, especially for those in the early stages of their careers. PEA attempts to grasp the frequency and character of protest events via different content analysis methods and can provide insights into the dynamics of protest, particularly in long-term observation periods (spanning years or even decades). Even under “normal” conditions, PEA is confronted with various challenges, such as reporting biases regarding the number of participants, discrepancies in local and national news coverage, and selection of those protest events being reported on. The pandemic further exacerbated suboptimal research conditions due to a high number of unannounced or banned demonstrations and ethical, legal, health, and security concerns for journalists.

On 10 October, the project team hosted an international workshop to present the study’s results and to debate challenges. This event followed up on an expert discussion held in Dresden in April 2022, which gave a first look at the protest situation in Saxony and Baden-Württemberg and provided a forum for discussing research approaches and difficulties.

On this occasion, the emphasis laid on results and insights into the anti-corona protests in Poland and Germany, which was the focus of this workshop. Much like the German study, the Polish sub-project also has its data basis in newspaper articles. However, because of the distinct media landscapes in both countries, the methods of data collection had to be adapted. While the local newspapers in Saxony and Baden-Württemberg report quite consistently about protest events in the area, the coverage of local events in Polish papers is sporadic and spread across a large number of sources. Additionally, due to the applied search algorithm, researchers had to deal with a high percentage of irrelevant results: The German team had gathered roughly 8.000 newspaper articles overall, whereas, on the Polish side, this number exceeded 90.000 – with a vanishingly low share of relevant texts. As a consequence, more time was needed to process the text corpus manually. Nonetheless, protest trends could be identified: Alongside minor phases of high intensity, demonstrations in Poland peaked in October 2020 with 68 events on a single day. Both in Saxony and Baden-Württemberg, the main periods of protest were detected in a longitudinal temporal section in December 2021.

In the workshop’s second part, the stage belonged to Daniel Platek (ISP PAN), who gave a keynote on “Protest Event Analysis of (not only) the Extreme Right in Poland”, in which he offered an overview of his past research projects. In his eyes, PEA’s principal challenge lies in identifying the greatest possible percentage of protest events in the shortest possible amount of time. Since the total number of actual protests is unknown, only a fraction of this basic population can be extracted from sources like newspaper articles or official statistics. The task, therefore, is to develop a tool which delivers maximal results while at the same time remaining subject to minimal bias. Once this problem is solved, the second challenge presents itself, namely reducing the time and effort of manually coding the data – which will only become more relevant, the more the data base grows.

For illustration purposes, Platek presented three of his projects: a study of the extreme right between 1990 and 2013, a study of the workers’ movement from 2004 to 2016, and a study of the recent protests in the year 2020. He devoted particular attention to comparing the yield of data in different news sources.

To date, no suitable alternative exists to manually select and code the material – thus, researchers will have to continue to laboriously process texts by hand. A starting point, however, lies in Natural Language Processing, with which computers are taught to correctly understand (written) language and its nuances. By these means, information such as event locations or participant numbers can be extracted from texts automatically. More complex tasks like “reading out” claims or acts of violence, though, require an interpretive effort that presents enormous challenges to Natural Language Processing.

The following discussion provided an opportunity to tackle open questions, such as the role of social media and local news. As a pilot study, the project was able to generate valuable insights into the protest situation in Poland and Germany. On the one hand, it underlined the appeal of further research, while on the other hand also stressing the need to adapt research methods to growing data volumes and shifting channels of information. In cross-border comparisons going forward, even between neighbouring countries, it will be necessary to find ways to deal with differing media landscapes and to develop search tools that precisely fit the situations at hand.

Funded by the German-Polish Science Foundation

Gefördert aus Mitteln der Deutsch-Polnischen Wissenschaftsstiftung

Projekt wspierany przez Polsko-Niemiecką Fundację na rzecz Nauki

Cite as: Elisabeth Oertel, „Workshop Report: Protest Event Analysis in the Covid-19 Pandemic: Methodological challenges and new ideas”. In: Denken ohne Geländer. Der Blog des Hannah-Arendt-Institut für Totalitarismusforschung e.V. vom 15.03.2023: https://haitblog.hypotheses.org/4026/2

Picture: HAIT, IFiS PAN, ipb, DPWS


OpenEdition schlägt Ihnen vor, diesen Beitrag wie folgt zu zitieren:
haitblog (15. März 2023). Workshop Report: Protest Event Analysis in the Covid-19 Pandemic: Methodological challenges and new ideas. Denken ohne Geländer. Abgerufen am 14. November 2026 von https://doi.org/10.58079/pf25


Das könnte dich auch interessieren …